Putting Economics at the Center: Munich’s New SEP Guidelines

Putting Economics at the Center: Munich’s New SEP Guidelines

Putting Economics at the Center: Munich’s New SEP Guidelines

Held on Wednesday 21 October 2026

Read the Presentation

Click on the articles to access the full analysis


Read the Presentation


1 / 8

Watch the recording


Pressing play loads the video from YouTube, which may store data in your browser.

Continue the conversation with OxFirst Club

Join us in Oxford and Munich

Two flagship Fora for the international patent, FRAND, licensing and competition community in 2027.

Rhodes House, University of Oxford

Oxford

15th IP and Competition Forum

13–14 January 2027
University of Oxford

Max-Joseph-Saal, Residenz Munich

Munich

16th IP and Competition Forum

2–3 June 2027
Residenz Palace, Munich

A senior international community across industry, law, economics and policy – continuing the conversation on IP, standards, licensing and competition.

Munich venue photo: Rainer Herrmann

About the speakers


Speakers

The Honorable Dr Oliver Schön, Presiding Judge, Munich I Regional Court

The Honorable Dr Oliver Schön, Presiding Judge, Munich I Regional Court

Dr Oliver Schön is the Presiding Judge of the 7th Civil Chamber at the Munich I Regional Court, where he focuses on patent infringement proceedings. He began working in patent law in 2008 and has undertaken several specialist secondments, including serving as a research assistant to the Xth Civil Senate of Germany’s Federal Court of Justice, which handles patent matters. He regularly speaks on patent litigation, FRAND/SEP disputes and developments in European intellectual property law.

Chris Longman, Vice President, Qualcomm

Chris Longman, Vice President, Qualcomm

Chris Longman is Vice President and Legal Counsel at Qualcomm. His work encompasses major patent and intellectual-property disputes, including issues concerning standard-essential patents, licensing and international patent enforcement. He regularly participates in international discussions on SEP litigation, global patent strategy and the relationship between intellectual property rights and technology standards.

Dr Corin Gittinger, Partner, Freshfields

Dr Corin Gittinger, Partner, Freshfields

Corin Gittinger is a Partner in Freshfields’ intellectual property practice, focusing on patent litigation. He advises and represents companies in international patent disputes and licensing negotiations, with particular expertise in standard-essential patents and the intersection of patent and competition law. His work spans the telecommunications, consumer electronics, automotive and IoT sectors.

Dr Clemens-August Heusch, LL.M., Vice President, Head of Global Litigation and Disputes, Nokia

Dr Clemens-August Heusch, LL.M., Vice President, Head of Global Litigation and Disputes, Nokia

Clemens-August Heusch is Vice President at Nokia and heads the Global Litigation and Disputes Team. He is responsible for litigation, arbitration and mediation globally with a strong focus on multinational IP litigation and licensing (FRAND) arbitrations. Since 2008 Nokia has been involved in more than 200 patent cases worldwide against companies such as Apple, HTC, Blackberry, InterDigital, Qualcomm, Daimler, Intellectual Ventures, IPCom, KPN, Daimler, Lenovo, Oppo, Vivo, Amazon, HP and others. Those patent cases related to implementation patents as well as to SEPs relating to GSM, UMTS, LTE, H.264, WiFi, NFC and others.

Scott Hayden, Vice President, Amazon

Scott Hayden, Vice President, Amazon

Scott Hayden leads Amazon’s intellectual-property group, with responsibility spanning patents, trademarks, copyright, trade secrets, IP licensing and domain matters. He joined Amazon in 2006 and has overseen the substantial expansion of both its global IP team and patent portfolio. Before Amazon, he held senior intellectual-property and legal positions at General Electric.

Andrew Yen, Chief IP Counsel, Panasonic IP Management Co.

Andrew Yen, Chief IP Counsel, Panasonic IP Management Co.

Andrew Yen is Chief IP Counsel at Panasonic’s R&D division, where he is responsible for bilateral licensing, patent pools, global litigation and policy matters involving standardisation, SEPs and FRAND. He has played a central role in developing Panasonic’s outbound cellular SEP licensing programme and leads work combining technical, legal and valuation analysis in global licensing negotiations.

What the discussion was about


On 13 August 2026, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Munich I Regional Court issued new FRAND Guidelines that move well beyond injunctions and negotiating conduct. The Court sets out in unusual detail how it intends to approach the economics of FRAND, including comparable licences, royalty ranges, top-down calculations, portfolio strength, patent counting, geographic differences and economic evidence.

For patent litigators, the implications are immediate. Which comparables will withstand scrutiny? How should portfolio strength be proved or challenged? And what economic evidence will now be needed to persuade the Court that a proposed royalty is, or is not, FRAND?

THE ISSUES ON THE TABLE

A focused discussion on the economics of FRAND

Comparable evidence, portfolio value, methodology and proof – examined through the lens of Munich’s new guidance.

Comparable licences
What counts as genuinely comparable?
Royalty ranges
How wide is a defensible FRAND range?
Top-down calculations
When does the methodology help?
Portfolio strength
How should quality and value be shown?
Patent counting
When do numbers mislead?
Geography & evidence
How should global differences be treated?