By Roya Ghafele
Private capacity disclaimer All webinar participants cited here spoke in their private capacities. Their comments reflect personal views and do not represent their employers, organisations or institutions. Affiliations are provided solely for identification.
Intellectual property protects innovation. Its institutions must be prepared to innovate too. We cannot keep assessing new technologies through familiar habits simply because those habits are comfortable. When the businesses, products and markets before a court change, the way we understand them must develop. That was my starting point at OxFirst’s webinar on Munich’s new FRAND Guidelines, and it remains the reason I find the initiative encouraging.
When I read the Guidelines, issued on 13 August 2026 by Munich I Regional Court’s 7th Civil Chamber, I saw a willingness to try. The court had set out its thinking on the economics of patent licensing in unusual detail. Welcoming that initiative does not mean endorsing every calculation. What deserves recognition is the decision to put a method into the open, where others can examine it, challenge it and help improve it.
That willingness matters because patent decisions reach beyond the parties in court. They can affect access to technology and the rewards available to those who develop it. They influence the conditions under which businesses build products and negotiate licences. Courts therefore confront questions with consequences for economic and technology policy. The analytical tools supporting their decisions should match the importance of those responsibilities.
Economics has a clear contribution to make. A court assessing a licence on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms faces a commercial question: what payment has a defensible basis? The answer requires attention to transactions, market conditions and the contribution of the rights being licensed. Negotiating conduct still matters. Munich’s Guidelines make scrutiny of the proposed royalty more explicit, asking parties to bring evidence of value into the argument.
The significance lies in that demand for explanation. A price should come with reasons that others can follow. If an agreement is a useful benchmark, explain why. If its terms require adjustment, show the calculation. If a portfolio deserves a particular share of royalties, identify the evidence supporting that share. This creates a more useful conversation between legal rules and the economic activity those rules govern.
My presentation drew a comparison with Unwired Planet v Huawei. The English proceedings helped establish the importance of comparable licences and used the top-down analysis as a cross-check. Munich is developing related methods within its own legal framework, including its treatment of FRAND as a range. This is one way institutions innovate: they learn from experience elsewhere, adapt the useful elements and expose the adaptation to scrutiny.
The comparison also shows why borrowing a method is only the beginning. Commercial agreements differ. A licence may cover several standards, past use or reciprocal rights. A payment upfront does not immediately tell us the rate per device. Economic analysis must explain how those differences affect the inference drawn from a transaction. Otherwise, a method that looks disciplined can simply reproduce an unexplained price.
Streaming makes the need for new thinking immediate. Transferring a familiar device calculation to a service without testing its assumptions would leave the central economic question unanswered.
This is where criticism becomes productive. A published model lets parties identify the assumptions they dispute and supply better evidence. At the webinar, the Honourable Judge Dr Oliver Schön explained that the streaming illustration invited parties to bring facts before the court. The assumptions must therefore remain open to challenge. The invitation gives practitioners and experts an opportunity to improve the analysis through the circumstances of a real business, rather than arguing only at the level of principle.
Progress also requires a distinction between a court explaining its current approach and declaring the final answer. The Guidelines consolidate recent decisions. Their value will grow if they help future parties identify weaknesses, bring better facts and show where a different treatment is justified by evidence.
Better decisions require knowledge that no single profession holds. Judges bring knowledge of adjudication. Economists examine value and incentives. Licensing practitioners understand how agreements take shape. Their perspectives will not always align. That disagreement can reveal where an apparently clear approach overlooks something important and where research would make the greatest difference.
For OxFirst, bringing economics into intellectual property and competition law is the purpose of our work. A valuation should explain what drives the value of a right and how uncertainty affects the decision. Munich’s initiative creates room to advance that work. Its usefulness will depend on whether stronger evidence changes the analysis when the facts justify it. Innovation in patent law will earn its value through better reasoning about the technologies and businesses it governs.
Sources
Opening remarks and presentation at the OxFirst webinar, 21 October 2026: https://oxfirst.club/webinar-munich-sep-guidelines/#oxf-recording
Accompanying PowerPoint presentation on the Munich FRAND Guidelines and Unwired Planet v Huawei.



